Submission Date


Document Type

Paper- Restricted to Campus Access



Faculty Mentor

Seamus Mulryan


Presented during the 24th Annual Summer Fellows Symposium, July 22, 2022 at Ursinus College.

Project Description

As our modern world places greater emphasis on the value of “finding our truths,” or discovering our identity and what matters to us, the field of education struggles to recognize that ethical formation is inherent to our identity development. In this paper, I discuss the social and individual ramifications of neglecting what Robert Kunzman calls “Ethical Dialogue” in the classroom and, drawing from Charles Taylor, the consequences of sustaining a culture via relativistic ideals. I expand this argument by advocating for the inclusion of Hans Georg Gadamer’s theory of hermeneutic experience in educational practice. Gadamer’s “hermeneutic circle” is a model of understanding that requires a student break from the chains that bind them to their perception of reality, as illustrated in Plato’s allegory of the cave, and dialogue is only effective in inciting a productive change that advances one’s self-understanding when its interlocutors are critically engaging with the values that constitute each individual’s identity. While I conclude with a “methodology” section on how to create more opportunities for this experience in the classroom, I acknowledge the challenges of institutionalizing this educational philosophy.


Available to Ursinus community only.